Albania and Macedonia should start EU accession talks, but human rights abuses mean Turkey talks should stay on hold, the European Commission is to say.
“In light of progress achieved, the European Commission recommends that accession negotiations be opened with Albania”, the commission is to say in its yearly enlargement report, due out on Tuesday (17 April), according to a draft seen by EUobserver.
Subscribe now for a 30 day free trial.
- €150 per year
- or €15 per month
- Cancel anytime
EUobserver is an independent, not-for-profit news organization that publishes daily news reports, analysis, and investigations from Brussels and the EU member states. We are an indispensable news source for anyone who wants to know what is going on in the EU.
We are mainly funded by advertising and subscription revenues. As advertising revenues are falling fast, we depend on subscription revenues to support our journalism.
If you already have an account click here to login.
The draft used the same formula for Macedonia.
The recommendation is the first for Albania. It comes 15 years after it signed its first EU ‘stabilisation’ pact and some 10 years after the Western Balkan state, which used to be a communist dictatorship, joined Nato.
The commission has been saying Macedonia was ready to start talks since 2005.
EU states never agreed to do so because Greece vetoed it on grounds that Macedonia’s name represented a territorial claim to a neighbouring Greek region of the same name.
But Tuesday’s recommendation comes amid EU hopes that Skopje and Athens are close to finding a solution, enabling the EU Council to actually open talks with Macedonia later this year.
It also comes amid a new commission strategy to speed up enlargement.
Reformist ‘frontrunners’, such as Serbia and Montenegro, should be able to join the EU in 2025, it said in a strategy paper in February, amid preparations for a special Western Balkans summit in Sofia in May.
EU foreign ministers will also discuss the Western Balkans at a meeting in Luxembourg on Monday.
They will restate their “commitment to facilitate dialogue between Serbia and Kosovo” on normalising relations and discuss security issues in the region, an EU diplomat said.
They might also discuss how to refer to Kosovo, which is not recognised by five EU states, in the Sofia summit declaration, the diplomat added.
The EU speed-up on Western Balkans stands in contrast to its standstill on Turkey.
Turkey started accession talks in 2005. They went slowly, then ground to a halt two years ago amid a failed coup against Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdogan and his subsequent crackdown.
“Respect of the rule of law and fundamental rights and freedoms is an essential obligation, which Turkey must meet as a candidate country. The continuing negative trend in these areas do not justify the opening of new negotiating chapters in the accession process,” the commission’s draft report on Turkey said.
It urged Turkey to lift its state of emergency and spoke of “serious backsliding” on issues such as jailing journalists, judges, and opposition MPs.
“Bilateral relations with several EU member states deteriorated markedly in 2017 and Turkey’s leadership resorted to extremely offensive and unacceptable rhetoric,” the commission added, referring to Erdogan’s jibes against “Nazi” practices in Germany, among other comments.
The commission’s draft report commended Turkey’s “outstanding efforts” in sheltering almost four million refugees and confirmed that it wanted to renew a deal with Erdogan to stop them from coming to Greece in return for EU aid and other perks.
“The cooperation with the EU on migration continued to deliver concrete and remarkable results”, it said.
It noted that Erdogan met with top EU officials in March in Varna, Bulgaria.
But that mini-summit was created to help him save face after being excluded from the Western Balkans enlargement summit in Sofia in May, EU sources said, and after the commission decoupled Turkey from its Western balkans push in February’s strategy document.
“The Turkish government reiterated its commitment to EU accession, but this has not been matched by corresponding measures and reforms,” the commission draft report said.